
Absolutely, being a good job interviewer is a skill that can be developed, and it’s far more than just asking questions from a list. In my experience, the most effective interviewers shift their mindset from “grilling” a candidate to evaluating fit through a structured, respectful conversation. The core of a good interview is preparation. Before the candidate even walks in, I review the job description, their resume, and prepare a list of questions tied directly to the key competencies for the role. This isn’t about tricking them; it’s about gathering consistent data.
The most critical step is to use a structured interview format. This means asking every candidate for the same role the same core questions. This significantly reduces bias and allows you to compare apples to apples. For example, instead of asking “Tell me about yourself,” I’d ask, “Can you describe a specific time you had to manage a project with a tight deadline and conflicting priorities?” This is a behavioral question based on the principle that past behavior is the best predictor of future performance. I also use a rating scale for each answer to maintain objectivity.
Another key is active listening. I’m not just waiting for my turn to talk; I’m focusing on their answers, asking follow-up questions, and paying attention to non-verbal cues. A good interviewer also sells the company and the role. This is a two-way street. If a candidate leaves feeling respected and informed, even if they don’t get the job, they’ll have a positive view of your brand. Finally, I always take notes immediately after the interview to capture my thoughts, not just the candidate’s answers. This makes the debriefing process with the hiring team much more efficient and data-driven.
| To illustrate the difference in effectiveness, consider Type | Predictive Validity of Job Performance | Key Characteristic |
|---|---|---|
| Unstructured Interview | 0.20 (low) | Casual conversation, no standard questions |
| Structured Behavioral Interview | 0.50-0.60 (high) | Same questions for all, anchored rating scale |
| Work Sample Test | 0.54 (high) | Candidate performs actual job tasks |
As you can see, a structured approach is far more reliable. It’s not about being robotic; it’s about being fair and effective.

For me, being a good interviewer is all about preparation and empathy. I spend 30 minutes before every interview mapping out the candidate’s career path on their resume. I look for patterns, like steady promotions or a shift in industry. Then, I prepare questions that explore those transitions. The biggest mistake I see is interviewers who just read the resume out loud. I focus on the gaps between the lines. I also make sure to create a comfortable environment from the start. A simple “How was your commute?” can break the ice. I want the candidate to be themselves, not a nervous wreck, so I can see who they really are. That’s how you get a genuine read on someone.

My approach is simple: listen more than you talk. I ask a question, then stay quiet. It’s amazing what people will fill the silence with. I’m not a fan of the “tell me about your strengths and weaknesses” cliché. Instead, I ask about a project they’re proud of and one that didn’t go as planned. The key is to probe for specifics, not generalities. If they say “I’m a great team player,” I ask “Give me a specific example of a conflict you resolved on a team.” I also keep a cheat sheet of the required competencies next to me and mentally tick them off as the candidate demonstrates them. It keeps the conversation focused and productive.

What makes a good interviewer? I believe it’s the ability to assess potential, not just past experience. I look for people who are adaptable and curious. I ask questions about how they’ve learned a new skill or adapted to a change in technology. A good interviewer also manages time well. I stick to a schedule, ensuring I have time for the candidate’s questions at the end. Their questions are a goldmine of information; they reveal what they value in a workplace. I also avoid any questions that could be legally questionable or introduce bias, like asking about age or family plans. The focus is always on the job requirements and the candidate’s ability to perform them.

I think the best interviewers are great storytellers in reverse. They don’t just take a resume; they help the candidate tell the story of their career. My style is conversational but purposeful. I’ll start with a big-picture question, like “What excites you about this industry right now?” This gets them talking about their passion. Then, I drill down into specifics. The most important thing is honesty. I’m honest about the challenges of the role, not just the perks. If the job has a lot of administrative work, I say so. I’ve found that being transparent upfront leads to better hires who stay longer. I also take 5 minutes after the interview to write down the one word that best describes the candidate. That gut feeling, combined with the data from my notes, is usually very accurate.


